The election of 1940 tested both American democracy and tradition itself. With war raging abroad and the United States still grappling with the aftershocks of the Great Depression, Franklin D. Roosevelt attempted something no president had ever done before: win a third consecutive term in office. The race against Republican outsider Wendell Willkie was as much about global uncertainty as it was about America’s political future.
From 1936 to 1940: Roosevelt’s Second Term
Franklin D. Roosevelt had stormed to a landslide victory in the election of 1936, carrying every state but Maine and Vermont. Yet, his second term proved more complicated. The economy faltered again in 1937–38, leading critics to call it the “Roosevelt Recession.” His controversial attempt to pack the Supreme Court after repeated rulings against New Deal programs also drew fierce backlash, including from within his own Democratic Party.
Even so, Roosevelt’s New Deal reforms had reshaped American life and cemented his popularity among working-class voters, farmers, and minorities. As the 1940 campaign approached, he was still the central figure in American politics. The only question was whether he would break the two-term precedent set by George Washington.
The Growing Shadow of World War II
While domestic debates over the New Deal continued, events in Europe made the 1940 election unlike any before it. Nazi Germany had invaded Poland in 1939, prompting Britain and France to declare war. By the summer of 1940, Hitler’s forces had overrun most of Western Europe, leaving Britain to stand alone.
Americans remained deeply isolationist. The America First Committee, led by prominent figures like Charles Lindbergh, warned against U.S. intervention. Roosevelt, however, believed neutrality was dangerous in a world increasingly dominated by dictators. His “Arsenal of Democracy” speeches laid the groundwork for aiding the Allies without direct involvement.
This international crisis weighed heavily on Roosevelt’s decision to run again. Although he had privately resisted breaking tradition, he concluded that no other Democrat was prepared to lead the country through such peril.
A Divided Democratic Party
Roosevelt’s decision was not without controversy. His vice president, John Nance Garner, openly opposed a third term and even ran against him at the convention. James Farley, Roosevelt’s longtime campaign manager and Democratic National Committee chairman, also sought the nomination.
Despite this opposition, FDR was renominated with little difficulty. To balance the ticket, he dropped Garner and selected Secretary of Agriculture Henry A. Wallace as his new running mate, though many Southern Democrats were uneasy with Wallace’s liberal reputation. Eleanor Roosevelt played a critical role in smoothing tensions at the convention, delivering speeches that reassured nervous delegates.
Choosing Wendell Willkie
The Republican Party entered 1940 still reeling from its crushing defeat in 1936. The frontrunners were Senator Robert Taft of Ohio and Thomas Dewey, a crime-busting prosecutor from New York. Both, however, leaned strongly isolationist at a time when public opinion was slowly shifting toward aiding Britain.
Deadlock at the GOP convention paved the way for a surprise compromise: Wendell Willkie, a corporate lawyer and businessman who had never held public office. Willkie had been a Democrat who once supported parts of the New Deal but opposed government programs like the Tennessee Valley Authority. His internationalist stance and charisma won over key delegates, and he secured the nomination with Charles McNary, the Senate Minority Leader, as his running mate.
Willkie’s sudden rise shocked political insiders. A Republican in name only, he appealed to moderates and urban liberals but struggled to gain trust among traditional conservatives.
Campaign Strategies
Roosevelt approached the campaign cautiously. He emphasized continuity and stability, arguing that it was too dangerous to change leadership during a global crisis. He promised to keep the U.S. out of war—“Your boys are not going to be sent into any foreign wars”—while simultaneously strengthening the military and increasing aid to Britain.
Willkie campaigned energetically, attacking Roosevelt’s decision to seek a third term as undemocratic and warning of creeping authoritarianism. He criticized the New Deal as bureaucratic overreach and accused Roosevelt of preparing to drag America into war. Still, Willkie supported many of FDR’s defense policies and ultimately aligned with the president on aid to Britain, blunting one of his strongest arguments.
The race also reflected the mood of the public. Polls showed most Americans disapproved of a third term, but they trusted Roosevelt’s steady hand more than an untested newcomer in uncertain times.
Election of 1940 Results
On Election Day, Franklin D. Roosevelt made history. He won 449 electoral votes and 54.7% of the popular vote, carrying 38 of 48 states. Wendell Willkie performed respectably for a first-time candidate, earning 82 electoral votes and 44.8% of the popular vote—better than any Republican since Hoover.
FDR became the first and only president elected to a third term, breaking Washington’s precedent. The nation had chosen continuity and experience over change, even while expressing unease with Roosevelt’s break from tradition.
Conclusion: From 1936 to 1944
The election of 1940 built directly on the themes of 1936: Roosevelt’s New Deal coalition remained dominant, but opposition to his policies was growing louder. By securing a third term, FDR ensured continuity during a time of global crisis.
Yet the promise of peace was short-lived. Within a year, the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor would thrust the U.S. into World War II. As we move into the election of 1944, Roosevelt would face an even greater test: leading a nation at war while seeking an unprecedented fourth term.
Leave a Reply